| User | Post |
|
10:10 pm
October 2, 2008
|
DavieC
Hard Core Urban Fly Fisher
| | | |
|
| posts 130 |
|
|
wasnt talking about race…. anyone who kills big pike should be educated … trout fishermen at kilbirnie especially…they kill pike 20lb+…i only said polish because the majority i see taking pike and all fish from any waters are Polish.. there were a few dams in paisley that held big pike and decent perch (i took a pair of 3lb ers)… they now hold no pike and little perch …
but a posted this… to see if anyone had caught a rainbow trout inthe kelvin
|
|
|
10:59 pm
October 8, 2008
|
mickey_woo
New Member
| | | |
|
| posts 5 |
|
|
I would not strictly say its the Polish, as Romanians, Albanians and Chinese folk are just as guilty for taking fish.
Personally I have been asked many times by Eastern European and Oriental folk for fish i was releasing back into the canal when im on a days coarse fishing. The standard “NO” reply is given and most people leave be, however myself and my buddies have almost taken to some more stubborn people in for an impromptu swim.
Did you know that by law any fish caught in freshwater under in Germany has to be killed by law? Was just told that by a German friend of mine who is a coarse match fisherman over there. I can only wonder how they can control their dwindling fish population.
|
|
|
11:39 pm
October 8, 2008
|
Alistair
Admin
| | aliferste | |
|
| posts 210 |
|
|
Did you know that by law any fish caught in freshwater under in Germany has to be killed by law?
Yes, and they must sit an exam on how to fish before they are allowed to - many I reckon would not pass it over here!
|
|
|
10:24 am
October 9, 2008
|
Campbell S
Kelvinator
| | | |
|
| posts 39 |
|
|
An exam would be good, but i think the strict kill policy is archaic. Education is the best way to ensure that people respect their quarry. I hate seeing people roughly handling fish, especially fish they do not value as a good sport.
|
|
|
11:14 am
October 9, 2008
|
DavieC
Hard Core Urban Fly Fisher
| | | |
|
| posts 130 |
|
|
LOOK A PUT THIS POST UP TO ASK ABOUT ANYONE ELSE CATCHING RAINBOWS IN THE KELVIN …. WHO CARES WHAT NATIONALITY THE PEOPLE ARE …THEY ARE KILLING THE CARP AND PIKE AND EVERY OTHER FISH IN OUR LOCHS AND RIVERS … IF U WANT TO TALK ABOUT THAT LOT THEN OPEN UP ANOTHER TOPIC …
|
|
|
11:20 am
October 9, 2008
|
ANDY C
Bushinator
| | | |
|
| posts 274 |
|
|
Alistair said:
Did you know that by law any fish caught in freshwater under in Germany has to be killed by law?
Yes, and they must sit an exam on how to fish before they are allowed to - many I reckon would not pass it over here!
its scotland not germany
|
|
|
12:11 pm
October 9, 2008
|
Stuart B
Hard Core Urban Fly Fisher
| | | |
|
| posts 111 |
|
|
DavieC said:
LOOK A PUT THIS POST UP TO ASK ABOUT ANYONE ELSE CATCHING RAINBOWS IN THE KELVIN …. WHO CARES WHAT NATIONALITY THE PEOPLE ARE …THEY ARE KILLING THE CARP AND PIKE AND EVERY OTHER FISH IN OUR LOCHS AND RIVERS … IF U WANT TO TALK ABOUT THAT LOT THEN OPEN UP ANOTHER TOPIC …
Calm down…Calm down
and
Please stop SHOUTING
|
|
|
1:52 pm
October 9, 2008
|
Alistair
Admin
| | aliferste | |
|
| posts 210 |
|
|
DavieC said:
the Polish should be in Poland…sick of seeing them hauling pike and everyother thing in the water out and taking home… Need to educate them on sport fishing ..and if they dont listen then re educate them with a bat!!
Actually Davy it was yourself that started the discussion on how best to educate people on good fishing practces (see above)
Anyway, you are quite right it is not to my taste to discuss what nationality anyone is and what they do or dont do.
As the law stands anyone can kill coarse fish for food whatever nationality they are.
I am as concerned about Scottish anglers mis handling fish as i am with anyone else.
|
|
|
1:54 pm
October 9, 2008
|
Alistair
Admin
| | aliferste | |
|
| posts 210 |
|
|
Campbell S said:
An exam would be good, but i think the strict kill policy is archaic. Education is the best way to ensure that people respect their quarry. I hate seeing people roughly handling fish, especially fish they do not value as a good sport.
I wonder what there reasoning is behind the kill all approach - I doubt it works - if you lived in germany and you fished a wee stream would you not just slip the fish back anyway and if anyone asked just say you had cought nowt 
|
|
|
6:37 pm
October 9, 2008
|
DavieC
Hard Core Urban Fly Fisher
| | | |
|
| posts 130 |
|
|
Actually Davy it was yourself that started the discussion on how best to educate people on good fishing practces (see above)
Anyway, you are quite right it is not to my taste to discuss what nationality anyone is and what they do or dont do.
As the law stands anyone can kill coarse fish for food whatever nationality they are.
I am as concerned about Scottish anglers mis handling fish as i am with anyone else.
its Davie  … well i do apologise … They should be educated …
|
|
|
11:02 pm
October 10, 2008
|
mickey_woo
New Member
| | | |
|
| posts 5 |
|
|
DavieC said:
LOOK A PUT THIS POST UP TO ASK ABOUT ANYONE ELSE CATCHING RAINBOWS IN THE KELVIN …. WHO CARES WHAT NATIONALITY THE PEOPLE ARE …THEY ARE KILLING THE CARP AND PIKE AND EVERY OTHER FISH IN OUR LOCHS AND RIVERS … IF U WANT TO TALK ABOUT THAT LOT THEN OPEN UP ANOTHER TOPIC …
Oops
Ok back to the original question, never caught one but seen a couple lying up by the old mill at Belmont street bridge.
|
|
|
8:51 am
October 12, 2008
|
ANDY C
Bushinator
| | | |
|
| posts 274 |
|
|
|
9:10 am
October 12, 2008
|
DavieC
Hard Core Urban Fly Fisher
| | | |
|
| posts 130 |
|
|
ave never seen rainbows in the kelvin other than the one i ve caught … i dont care about dead ones they could have been left …a take it no one else has caught them
|
|
|
9:12 am
October 12, 2008
|
ANDY C
Bushinator
| | | |
|
| posts 274 |
|
|
|
9:17 am
October 12, 2008
|
DavieC
Hard Core Urban Fly Fisher
| | | |
|
| posts 130 |
|
|
Just me Yay… a should get a badge
|
|
|
9:19 am
October 12, 2008
|
ANDY C
Bushinator
| | | |
|
| posts 274 |
|
|
|
11:10 am
October 12, 2008
|
DavieC
Hard Core Urban Fly Fisher
| | | |
|
| posts 130 |
|
|
|
11:14 am
October 12, 2008
|
ANDY C
Bushinator
| | | |
|
| posts 274 |
|
|
|
1:31 am
October 16, 2008
|
mickey_woo
New Member
| | | |
|
| posts 5 |
|
|
ANDY C said:
when
A few years ago, twas during the summer right below the weir at the end of the old mill run.
|
|
|
10:13 am
October 16, 2008
|
ANDY C
Bushinator
| | | |
|
| posts 274 |
|
|
mickey_woo said:
A few years ago, twas during the summer right below the weir at the end of the old mill run.
it was a few years ago my mate caught a nice 1 we still dont know wher it came from but it must have bn in the water 4 some time coz all of the fins on it . not like the 1s u get from a fishery way all there tails and fins chewd. it was a lovely 1 no marks no chew fins
|
|
Login
Register
Search 
Forums
